Ian Silverman, Rabbi

rabbi10

View current news articles, commentary, videos and more that have an impact on Jewish culture, politics and religion at Rabbi Silverman's Sites to See

 

When it comes to the Gregorian calendar, there are things we Jews do and things we don't do: the Peculiar case of Birkat Tal u'Matar vs. Thanksgiving

(This gets a bit complicated so put on your thinking cap!)

Some wonder why, in our standing devotion (Amidah), we request that God send "dew and rain" for a blessing from December 4th until Passover [and discontinued after]. Why is this tied to the secular calendar and not to the Jewish calendar? Actually, in Israel, it is tied to the Jewish calendar because the blessing for "dew and rain" (Tal u’Matar) begins on Cheshvan 7 each year. Why? This is because the Israelis didn't want rain for two weeks when they began their pilgrimage back from Jerusalem. Who needed mud and rain during travel?


It was the Jewish community of Babylonia, followed by all of the diaspora, that decided to wait 60 days following the autumnal equinox (Sept 23) to recite the blessing, because the harvested crops took 2 months to fully dry. Well then, why do we not begin to pray for rain on Nov. 22, which would be 60 days from the Autumnal Equinox? The answer is that Pope Gregory, in the 16th century, decided to rob October of ten days to correct a discrepancy in the calculation of the length of the year. Unlike the Greco-Roman Julian calendar, which assumed the length of the year to be 365.25 days, the actual time computation, based on the earth's orbit, is 365.2422 days. That difference would henceforth be corrected, according to Gregory, by not taking a leap day (a Feb 29) during the century year unless it was a century year divisible by 400 (which is why we had a leap day in Feb. in the year 2000). It was determined by astronomers of the day that the calendar had gotten 10 days ahead of itself. So these ten days were omitted in that year of 1583.

The Jewish community of that century didn't accept the correction to the Julian Calendar. As far as they were concerned, the 60 days from the Equinox would henceforth fall on December 2, not November 22! So why are we now beginning prayer for rain on December 4th? Because they also didn't accept Pope Gregory's correction to omit a leap day each century year. Therefore, in 1700, the date advanced to December 3. In 1800, the date advanced an additional day to December 4th. In 1900, many prayer books failed to make the adjustment to December 5. In 2000 both the Julian and Gregorian calendar agreed to include a leap day. Presumably, if prayer books do due diligence in the future, the prayer will advance to December 5 in 2100, where it should have been already, and to December 6 in the next century, 2200. Fast forward 30,000 years or so, and our descendants will pray for winter rains as we approach summer! But we should be so fortunate that Judaism has the staying power to have such problems! Or who knows, some great sage in a future era may say we should accept Pope Gregory's leap day omission on century years.


We have, however, some unanimity to accept the November computation of Thanksgiving as the 4th Thursday in November. There are some ultra-Orthodox communities that don't believe in observing any holiday on the secular calendar–only Jewish ones–but most traditional communities of the last 150 years or so accept the observance of the civic holiday of Thanksgiving. There ought not to be a problem observing a civic holiday that all Americans mark. Most importantly, Thanksgiving, as currently observed, is a day of gratitude to God for the precious blessings our country and our God bestows. That, actually, is a Jewish imperative every day of the year. We mark that very sentiment each and every day when recite the psalm in the morning "it is good to give thanks to God and to sing Your praises on High!" Naturally, it can and should be marked with our dietary restrictions and so forth as American stands for the right of all to practice their religion. We also have no problem with observing it on the appropriate day rather than 10 days later. Since it is anchored in the American calendar, which has accepted the Julian accounting of time, there is no reason to make adjustments.

If any of this information is wrong, by the way, because math is not my strong suit, please let me know! To quote Wilbur Cross' 1936 proclamation, "as the chill and frost begin to set in in these darkening days of autumn under the heel of Orion" Beth and I wish you and your families a year that is fertile and prosperous, a year of plenty–rich in blessings, and a very happy Thanksgiving.

Israel Committee Events

 

Watch a presentation by Israel Committee head Brian Tropper on the Israeli Nation State Law

Committee Meetings

Programs




 

Chai Institute

Israel Items of Interest

KEEP CURRENT WITH THE LATEST NEWS IN ISRAELI ADVOCACY, THE DAILY ALERT HERE.

An Israeli company has developed a means to evaluate the freshness of foods. Read about it HERE.

Israeli startup Zebra Medical Vision, offers an online software that can provide a second opinion on CT scans by analyzing the information and producing a medical report within 90% accuracy. Read about it HERE.

Film recommendation: Mekonen, the story of an Ethiopian Jew who makes peace with an emotional past and embraces his future in Israel, becoming a decorated officer in the IDF while remaining true to his African roots and culture.

Did you know that the first victim of 9-11 was an Israeli Special Forces Veteran who rushed the cockpit of American Airlines Flight 11 to stop the hijackers, but was murdered in his attempt to stop these al-Queda terrorists. Watch a quick video, HERE. 

Read about a small guitar workshop in Jaffa, creating the finest instruments, HERE.

A PhD student at Hebrew University has won an award for developing a test to detect Parkinson's Disease. Read about it HERE.

Three years after publishing an anti-Israel letter in the medical journal, The Lancet, the editor admits he has deep regrets and has dedicated the latest issue to highlighting health care in Israel. Read about it HERE.

Read an article by Chris Coons and Marco Rubio from the Wall Street Journal, "Every Senator Agrees the UN Must Change," HERE.

Israel's medical clowns- they cheer up sick kids, reduce anxiety, decrease pain, and alleviate depression. They are Jews, Christian Arabs, and others. Watch a YouTube video about them HERE.

Learn about the connection of Jews with Israel, the decades-long quest of Israel for peace with it's neighbors, the failure of Palestinian leadership to turn conflict into coexistence, and the contrast between the fate of Palestinian and Jewish refugees from the Arab-Israel conflict, HERE. 

Women of the IDF video

 

Rabbi Silverman's Suggested Sites to See

The father of solar energy was.... you guessed it– an Israeli! Read the story, HERE.

The National Women's Studies Association has awarded a Rutgers University professor for his book asserting that the Israeli Defense Forces, toward the debilitation of Palestine, claim a sovereign right to maim and kill Palestinians. Read about it HERE.

A University of California, San Diego professor shut up a Muslim student organization member (affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood) and revealed her true anti-Israel stance. Many of us are not aware of how radicalized some of our American Muslim students are. Watch the video HERE.

A professor at the University of Michigan refused to recommend student study in Israel, not because of the academic flaws of the student but because of the supposed "flaws" of the Jewish State and his BDS pledge. Please read and let the U of M administration know your opinion, HERE.

U.S.-born Ari Fuld, a well-known Israel advocate and activist was stabbed to death 9/16 by a Palestinian terrorist outside a West Bank shopping mall. A friend of Rabbi Ian's brother, who lived on the same street in Beit Shamesh, Fuld was a hero to all. Read a letter to the editor of the Jerusalem Post, expaining this random killing, HERE.

Read why Israel should have the Nation-State law, HERE.

The Israel Group, a non-profit fighting BDS, is demanding that the LA school district cease holding workshops promoting BDS and discrimination against Israel. The group publicized their findings of the 2017 workshop, finding that the material presented was a one-sided official condemnation of core Jewish religious beliefs and right of self-determination. Read about it HERE.

UCLA will host the Students for Justice in Palestine annual conference in November, whose mission is to "remind us that Zionism is not an insurmountable force...We can have hope that Zionism... can be destroyed." This rhetoric contributes to hostile and violent attitudes toward Jewish students on campuses throughout the US. Sign a petition demanding that UCLA adhere to its commitment to "mutual respect, equality and inclusion," and halt its compliance in fueling anti-Semitism in college settings, HERE.

Why are Palestinian refugees different from aother refugees? Read about the lunacy of the UNRWA HERE.

Watch a short and effective video about Hamas, painting a not-so-pretty picture for Palestinian inhabitants, HERE.

Urge your congressman to vote for the US-Israel Security Assistance Authorization Act, ensuring Israel has the means necessary to defend itself HERE.

Linda Sarsour warned Muslims against "humanizing" Israelis. Read about her speech at ISNA HERE.

Read an article by Rabbi Marc Gellman of the GodSquad on the mystery of blessings, HERE.

Read the latest article from Cold Spring Harbor's Judy Davis, " Has Israel Betrayed American Jews?" HERE.

CAIR, the Council of American Islamic Relations, has published its 2018 Civil Rights Report, finding an increase in Islamophobic incidents across the US. Ironically, the author of the report is herself a conspiracy bigot and anti-Semite. Read about it HERE.

Is British Labor leader Jeremy Corbyn an anti-Semite? Seems so... Read the evidence HERE.

Israeli PM Bibi Netanyahu recently visited his ancestral home of Vilna, Lithuania with his wife, and reflected on his visit HERE.

 

 

 

Although some argue that Jews are the alien population to Palestine, implanted by the British, in fact, Jews are the indigenous population in this area based on historical and genetic documentation. It is the Palestinians, however, who are there as a result of converts from those indigenous pre-modern Jews and Christians who submitted to Islam, Muslim invaders, and Arab immigrants. Read about it HERE. 

Learn the proper protocol to handle Palestinian activists on campuses as exemplified by Georgetown University HERE.

A video about all the wonderful aid Israel provides worldwide, that will bring a tear to your eyes HERE.

 

 

Buy Chai, Double Chai and larger multiples–– now available for gift purchase


(Click HERE to purchase)

 

Contact Us

The East Northport Jewish Center
328 Elwood Road
East Northport, NY, 11731  

Phone: 631-368-6474
Fax: 631-266-2910
Religious School Office: 631-368-6474

Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Religious School: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

CONGREGANT PORTAL

 

        

Upcoming Events

healthcare jobs washington dc

levitra uk

atrium pharmacy

doxycycline online

harmony korine drugs

levaquin online

prescription medication for leg cramps

buy tetracycline online

pills for a bigger booty

buy azithromycin online

metanx prescription

viagra

priority health insurance

dapoxetine uk online

google android 2.2 tablet

phentermine 37.5 mg

i need a doctor song

adderall online without a prescription

water pill for high blood pressure

lorazepam online

naturopathic doctor schools

ostaa viagra